Thursday, November 15, 2012
Reaching for an Object
Based on my own experience, being a tall person was something to be looked down upon especially in my family since the majority of relatives were on the shorter side. This had me thinking that I was the one who wasn't able to fit in. However, through social interactions and my peer group I learned that the opposite rang true at least with my school community: Tall was something to be admired and being short was literally a handicap. The way this was projected was through belittlement or self-deprecating humor about the larger differences and disadvantages between my height and someone else's. This picture shows someone short reaching for something from a higher surface. The image alone almost makes one think that the girl, while an adult, is a child and thus needs assistance and isn't capable of reaching the object above. Some assumptions made could be, that shorter people are considered as cute, and not as intelligent (if one was associating cute with that of being a child and a child with being naive) and not being able to do things independently. Assumptions like this are present in every day life whether acknowledged or not. There have been studies attempting to prove that tall height is synonymous with job success, or earning respect from groups of people, because a tall person seems more abled or with a 'strong', smart demeanor (Gandalf and all the Elves were unusually taller and supposedly wiser than any other characters in Lord of the Rings!) which places the opposite perception in a slightly negative light. I would assume that the girl in the photo would ask someone taller to get the object for her, instead of critically thinking of how she could get it herself (such as the use of a chair or a longer handle) which further perpetuates the issue of image and it's connection to actual ability and intelligence.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I have heard that people do tend to associate attractiveness with intelligence,but i have never heard of height associated with intelligence. Maybe its because I'm average height and these assumptions don't apply to me. I was wondering if this is something that you observed and so you know this is how people perceive shorter/ taller people, or if these are your beliefs? Also, I wonder if this can be related to the in-group/out-group theory. Because I'm sure that small people do not think of themselves as less intelligent than tall people, and I can assume that taller people came up the idea that they are more intelligent (I'm guessing). Especially if a taller person is assuming that, for example, a shorter person is not critically thinking about how to grab something out of reach, instead of coming to the conclusion that their may not be a step stool around, or that a taller person is around and having them do the reaching would just be the most efficient way of solving the problem.
ReplyDeleteVery interesting analysis. This ties in a little bit to my post on beauty! I think it is true that people unconsciously associate height with being "better." I always hear about taller people being seen as more confident, or having greater presence. I hadn't thought about height being associated with intelligence before, but it makes sense. Your last comments about the girl asking someone else to get her the object instead of thinking critically about how to get it was a good example.
ReplyDeleteThis is something. I don't really consider myself to be tall, but coming from a Mexican background the average Mexican is a short person, but my family tends to be on the taller side. I am taller than pretty much all my aunts, and slightly taller than most of my uncles. They do all tend to look at me as the intelligent one, that is going to school and working my way towards something other than manual blue collar employment. Do I think this is true? Nope. I don't think I'm more intelligent than any of them, I just feel as if we all know certain subjects better than others. I can see your rationale on shorter people being seen as not as capable, and in a world where the average height is increasing slowly that can be true in certain communities but your culture and environment are heavy factors on how this is viewed.
ReplyDelete